Emotional Threads: Unravelling Attachment in Circular Fashion

{{ vm.tagsGroup }}

11 Jul 2024

7 Min Read

Nellie Chan (Editor)

IN THIS ARTICLE

Pull on the threads of emotional attachment—memories, identities, and feelings—influencing sustainable fashion and contributing to a circular economy!

Imagine rummaging through your closet and stumbling upon an old, worn-out T-shirt from a concert you attended years ago—the fabric thinning, the print fading, and the seams fraying. Yet, despite its imperfections, you find yourself unable to let it go. This T-shirt, imperfect as it is, embodies a piece of your personal history. This emotional attachment to our old clothing often creates a reluctance to part with them, which can be both a blessing and a curse.

Assessing Circular Fashion

Interestingly, this reluctance can be harnessed with the rising trend of circular fashion, which aims to redefine our relationship with clothing (i.e., the blessing). The current fashion model operates in the linear economy of 'take, make, waste', dominating an industry that mass-produces and consumes garments primarily made from fossil fuel-based synthetics, such as polyester, nylon, and acrylic. This economy promotes not only fast fashion but also, at its worst, disposable fashion. However, recognising the severity of shrinking resources and growing consumer concerns about environmental and social impacts, the fashion industry is shifting towards a circular economy. 

 

In contrast, the circular economy seeks to keep garments in use for as long as possible, creating a closed-loop system. This economy is structured around four core principles: reduction, paring down new purchases; reuse, encouraging the reuse and repurposing of old clothes; recycle, breaking down garments to create new ones; and redesign, inspiring creativity in altering and updating clothing. By embracing these principles, individuals and industries can pave the way for a sustainable future where each piece of clothing continues to tell a story, preserving our personal histories while reducing our environmental footprint.

Clearing Out Clothing Attachment

But while our emotional attachment to clothing complements the principles of circular fashion, it also often complicates our efforts to support it (i.e., the curse). Clothing isn't just fabric; it's a memory vessel, carrying significant moments in our lives. This concept echoes the theory of object attachment—similar to John Bowlby's attachment theory in relationships—where we form deep emotional connections with certain pieces of clothing due to the memories and emotions they evoke, such as the T-shirt from the concert. Moreover, clothing can act as transitional objects, a concept introduced by Donald Winnicott, offering a sense of security and comfort during periods of stress or anxiety. These theories propose that emotional bonds with clothing influence our reluctance to part with them, even if they are no longer functional or fashionable.

 

Beyond memories, clothing also plays a crucial role in identity expression. Symbolic interactionism, a theory developed by George Herbert Mead, posits that society is socially constructed through human interpretation. According to this theory, individuals create and communicate subjective meanings about elements (i.e., clothing) in their environments through interactions with them, rather than relying solely on objective facts. For example, an individual may be reluctant to part with their varsity jacket from high school because it symbolises their identity as an athlete during that time. Social identity theory by Henri Tajfel and John Turner further suggests that clothing can express both personal and social (i.e., group) identities. Thus, this individual is more likely to hold onto their varsity jacket to reinforce their identity as an athlete and their sense of belonging to the high school athletic community.

 

Furthermore, the term 'enclothed cognition', introduced by Hajo Adam and Adam D. Galinsky describes how what we wear affects our psychological processes. Clothing can enhance our self-esteem and influence our behaviour, which in turn encourages us to hold onto these items longer. Consider the confidence gained from a well-tailored blazer before a big presentation or the comfort offered by a cosy sweater on a rainy day—these items become essential to our emotional well-being.

Sorting and Deciding Disposal (and Reuse) Factors

When it comes to letting go, behavioural psychology sheds light on why it can be so difficult. Loss aversion, a foundational concept in prospect theory by Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky, explains why we are more sensitive to losses than gains—it is theorised that the pain of losing is psychologically twice as powerful as the pleasure of gaining. When the thought of parting with clothing feels like losing a part of ourselves, it perpetuates a cycle of keeping one item after another, ultimately resulting in an overflowing closet. Decision fatigue, a term documented by Roy F. Baumeister, further exacerbates our reluctance to dispose of clothing. As we become overwhelmed with the sheer number of items in our closets, the decision-making process of what to keep or dispose of becomes increasingly burdensome.

 

Cultural norms also significantly impact disposal behaviours. In collectivist cultures, where passing down clothing through families or participating in communal swaps is common, there is a notable focus on community involvement in clothing reuse and sustainability. Conversely, individualist cultures often prioritise personal status through frequent purchases and subsequent disposal of new clothing. These cultural norms, identified in Geert Hofstede's cultural dimensions theory, affect how people approach clothing disposal.

 

Economic factors matter too. Disposable income allows individuals to afford sustainable practices like reuse and repair, which are viewed as investments in quality and durability. Economic constraints, however, may prompt individuals to opt for cheaper, fast-fashion alternatives that are more disposable. The affordability and accessibility of these options determine whether individuals can adopt sustainable practices or resort to less environmentally friendly choices.

Repairing and Maintaining Sustainable Clothing Habits

Therefore, with psychological, cultural, and economic factors impeding circular fashion, empowering strategies are essential. Encouraging conscious consumption through thoughtful reflection on our purchasing choices—spending less on quantity and more on quality—is key to fostering sustainable clothing habits. Embracing the principles of minimalism, which emphasises keeping only essential, functional, and sentimental items, can also help reduce consumption. The KonMari Method, popularised by Marie Kondo, recommends keeping only the items that 'spark joy' and discarding the rest with gratitude, promoting a more mindful approach to clothing.

 

Practical advice for addressing common garment issues like fraying seams or missing buttons can extend the life of clothing (i.e., longevity) and help them escape the fate of waste! For example, patching is perfect for fixing holes or tears in fabric, darning is great for repairing holes or snags in knitwear, and reinforcing material is ideal for preventing premature wear and tear in high-stress areas like elbows or knees. When all else fails, upcycling offers a creative and innovative solution to repurpose damaged garments into something simple, like dishcloths that require no sewing, or into something a little more complex, like tote bags that require some sewing.

 

Finally, community engagement plays a pivotal role in fostering sustainable clothing habits. Participating in community swaps, second-hand markets, and repair workshops cultivates norms around clothing reuse and nurtures a sense of community. According to social cognitive theory by Albert Bandura, individuals are active agents who can both influence and are influenced by their environment through observation and imitation. By seeing others engage in sustainable practices, individuals are more likely to do the same.

Who are the communities stitching together the future of circular fashion? Meet Kita—an e-commerce platform for thrift store vendors supported by BizPod, the startup incubator for Taylor's University. Catch them in action at their upcycling workshops during The Thrift Fiesta by REFASH, happening from July 16th to 18th, 2024!

Conclusion

As we reflect on the contents of our overflowing closets, we come to appreciate the profound emotional attachment we form with our clothing. Each piece tells a story, narrating the memories we cherish, the identities we embrace, and the feelings we preserve over time. Sifting through these sentiments, we are reminded of the transformative power of circular fashion: it transcends mere waste reduction; it stands as a testament to honouring our past while shaping a sustainable future. Despite the initial reluctance we may experience, learning to let go then becomes a meaningful act when seen through the lens of environmental stewardship. Every decision to reduce, reuse, recycle, redesign, or relinquish our old clothing to others contributes to a broader movement—one that celebrates our intimate connections with clothing and navigates a more conscientious way forward.

YOU MIGHT BE INTERESTED
{{ item.articleDate ? vm.formatDate(item.articleDate) : '' }}
{{ item.readTime }} Min Read