Can You Prove a Price Without Showing It?

{{ vm.tagsGroup }}

17 Nov 2026

10 Min Read

AP Ts Dr Chai Chang Sa'ar (Academic Contributor), The Taylor's Team (Editor)

IN THIS ARTICLE

When Malaysia's Public Accounts Committee (PAC) investigated Phase 1 of the Sabah Pan Borneo Highway this year, one finding stood out: fifty-seven changes to the contracted work, worth RM513.99 million, had been approved beyond the authorised limit, without sign-off from the Treasury or the Works Ministry's procurement board.

 

Changes like these are called variation orders, and they turn up on almost every construction project. Associate Professor Ts. Dr Chai Chang Sa'ar of Taylor's School of Architecture, Building and Design has spent most of his career watching them turn into disputes, first on construction sites in Malaysia and Singapore and now as a researcher in digital construction. With a new grant from the Ministry of Higher Education, Malaysia (MOHE), he is working on a question at the heart of the problem: what if every party to a contract could trust the same record of a change, without showing anyone its own figures?

When the Plans Change Mid-Build

A variation order is the formal record of a change to work already agreed in a construction contract. Once a change is requested, the work has to be re-measured and re-valued, then approved by several parties before anyone is paid for it. When those parties disagree on the cost, payment is held back, the project slows down and the disagreement can end in a formal dispute.

 

Most of that process still runs on emails, fax and separate project management apps, so there is no single record that every party shares. The quantity surveyor, the professional who measures and values construction work, often arrives at a different figure from the contractor, who has usually built the changed work already. 'Contractors bear the cost of changed work for months before receiving payment,' Dr Chai explains.

 

The Pan Borneo audit shows how quickly the problem builds. State and project authorities attributed the extra costs to difficult hilly terrain and shifting swamp and peat soils along the route. The same audit recorded price disputes totalling RM60.87 million across 13 items under 10 variation orders, and RM163.64 million in interim payments made before the formal contract paperwork was in place.

Construction workers on top of tall concrete bridge piers rising out of a forested river valley, with tower cranes and a completed highway deck behind them

'This is exactly the kind of problem we are trying to solve,' Dr Chai points out.

The Trust Problem He Saw on Site

Before he moved into academia, Dr Chai spent nearly ten years working in construction across Malaysia and Singapore. On site, the same problems kept coming back: documents scattered across different people and formats, approvals that arrived late and payments that turned into arguments. He came to see them as failures of trust between the parties to a contract, and that view has shaped his research in digital construction ever since.

 

In later academic roles, he directed a Digital Technology International Centre and widened his work into AR-BIM and digital twinning. AR-BIM overlays Building Information Modelling (BIM), the 3D digital models that hold a building's design and construction data, onto the real site through augmented reality. A digital twin is a live digital copy of a building or process that updates as the real one changes. Digital twinning became the subject of the first of two Fundamental Research Grant Scheme (FRGS) projects he has led as Principal Investigator (2019), and the second built a model for Construction 4.0 policy changes in Malaysia (2021).

 

The turning point came when he supervised a study on smart contract adoption in Malaysian construction. It showed a clear gap between what blockchain could offer and how ready the industry was to use it. Blockchain's permanent, tamper-resistant records spoke directly to the trust problems he had seen on site, and smart contracts suggested a way to check that each step followed the contract without relying on a middleman. That thinking now runs through his supervision of doctoral research on privacy-preserving smart contracts for construction procurement. Along the way, he has secured more than RM1 million in research funding as Principal Investigator, worked as a co-investigator on FRGS projects in AI-driven prediction and modular construction, received the Best Researcher Award in Digital Construction in 2025 and served on the editorial committee for the Construction Industry Development Board (CIDB) Construction 4.0 Strategic Plan (2021 to 2025).

A Shared Record That Keeps Prices Private

Dr Chai's answer to that trust problem is PriVOChain, the framework at the centre of his new 36-month project. It is a blockchain system that keeps a record of every step of a variation order that no single party can alter, while letting each party prove its figures meet the contract without revealing the figures themselves.

 

Most project systems sit on a conventional database, which has a central administrator who can change what it holds. A blockchain spreads the same record across many computers, so no single party controls it. Every transaction is timestamped and once written, cannot be altered, which means no one can go back and change what was approved on a variation order or how it was valued.

 

'That tamper-resistance is what shared databases cannot provide,' Dr Chai notes.

Illustration of glowing blue data blocks labelled with block hashes, linked one to the next by dashed lines like a chain

The working part of PriVOChain is a smart contract: a program stored on the blockchain that runs by itself once agreed conditions are met. He describes a variation order the way he would to a first-year student. The contractor submits the request on the blockchain, the consultant certifies the valuation and the employer, the client paying for the project, approves it. Once all three conditions are met, payment is released automatically, and every step carries a timestamp that all parties can see.

 

That visibility is what makes the record trustworthy. Yet if every step is open to every party, the figures behind each claim could be too, and that is an obvious worry for anyone in business. Contractors protect their profit margins and supplier prices, employers guard their budget allocations, and subcontractors keep their rates from competitors working on the same project. Today, proving that a claim complies with the contract usually means disclosing some of those figures, which discourages openness because no party wants its commercial position exposed.

 

PriVOChain answers this with zero-knowledge proofs, a cryptographic method that lets one party prove a statement is true without revealing the information behind it. Dr Chai compares it to applying for a loan: you can show the bank you have enough money to qualify without revealing your balance or transaction history, and the bank confirms you qualify without seeing any other financial details.

 

In a variation order, the contractor proves that a quoted price falls within the rate agreed in the contract, and the blockchain verifies that the claim is true. 'At no point is the cost breakdown or profit margin revealed to the other parties,' he shares. Each party can check compliance without ever seeing another's sensitive commercial data.

 

The system also has to cope with projects that keep changing. A standard smart contract cannot be changed once it is live, so PriVOChain uses an upgradable design known as a UUPS (Universal Upgradeable Proxy Standard) proxy, which keeps the contract's rules separate from the data it stores. The rules can be updated as a project evolves without losing the record of past transactions, and each upgrade is itself recorded on the blockchain and restricted to authorised parties.

Turning Contract Clauses Into Code

The hardest part of the project, Dr Chai expects, will be turning the wording of a construction contract into instructions a computer can run. 'Legal language is not easy to interpret, and smart contracts do not tolerate ambiguity,' he admits. The other test will be making zero-knowledge proofs run fast enough for everyday use on a live project.

 

He has built a team around both problems, drawing on contract management, construction technology and law. The work begins with what he calls a legal-digital ontology, a structured map that links each step of the variation order process to logic a smart contract can run. Associate Professor Ts. Dr Lee Chia Kuang of Universiti Malaysia Pahang Al-Sultan Abdullah (UMPSA) supports this early framework with DEMATEL (Decision-Making Trial and Evaluation Laboratory), a method for working out how different factors influence one another. Alongside him, Dr Zafira Nadia Maaz of Universiti Malaya brings the legal perspective, advising on the contractual issues in variation order management that the zero-knowledge proofs need to handle.

 

From there, the team designs the PriVOChain framework, combining the upgradable contracts with zero-knowledge proof circuits, and builds a working prototype on a test blockchain network. Sr Dr Soon Lam Tatt, Programme Director for the Bachelor in Quantity Surveying (Honours) at Taylor's and the project's next appointed leader, supports the automated variation order management through upgradable smart contracts. Associate Professor Ts. Dr Goh Kai Chen of Universiti Tun Hussein Onn Malaysia (UTHM) works on the smart contract infrastructure and its environmental, social and governance (ESG) dimension, and a graduate research assistant will join to code and test the contracts. Guiding the whole effort is Professor Chong Heap Yih of Nanjing Audit University in China, who mentors the team and oversees progress in digital construction and contract management.

 

In the final stage, experts will evaluate the prototype and run it through a simulated construction scenario using industry data from a Malaysian building project, before it is tested against real variation order cases supplied through an industry partnership. The project's strategic partner is the Construction Research Institute of Malaysia (CREAM), the research arm of CIDB, whose involvement gives the framework regulatory credibility and connects it to the digital goals of Ekonomi MADANI.

 

Partnerships like this are built into the Geran Penyelidikan Eksploratori dan Transformatif (GET), MOHE's new research grant for 2026, under which Dr Chai's project secured RM142,200 in Phase 2. Funded through the Research Sustainability Fund, the scheme supports both early-stage exploratory work and transformative projects aimed at changing policies, processes or systems, and it requires every application to include an industry collaborator, a patent search and a risk assessment. For Dr Chai, the award recognises this research direction at a national level, and the project supports the Thirteenth Malaysia Plan's focus on digital infrastructure and innovation-led growth. 'If it works, we show that compliance can be checked automatically without anyone exposing their commercial figures,' he adds.

 

Over the 36 months, the team aims to deliver a validated PriVOChain prototype, the legal-digital ontology and specifications for the zero-knowledge proof circuits, along with two indexed journal publications, two copyrights, a conference paper and a policy brief on blockchain adoption in Malaysian construction procurement.

Changing the Habit of 'Check Your Email'

Contractors stand to gain the most, in Dr Chai's view, since they would submit claims on the blockchain and be paid once approval is confirmed. Quantity surveyors would get a clear trail with less back-and-forth, consultants would have proper records if a dispute goes to adjudication, and employers could follow variation costs as they happen. 'The biggest shift is moving from chasing people on email to a shared system that triggers actions automatically,' he observes.

 

Getting there needs three things: Malaysian standard forms of contract, such as those from Pertubuhan Akitek Malaysia (PAM) and CIDB, would need to recognise on-chain records as valid documentation; quantity surveyors and project managers would need basic training in blockchain tools; and firms would have to be willing to leave familiar email-based workflows behind. The legal groundwork is already moving, with the Construction Industry Payment and Adjudication Act 2012 (CIPAA) and the Electronic Commerce Act 2006 providing a basis for recognising digital transactions. The harder barrier is working culture, since people tend to follow company habits or personal preference, and he expects that change to take time.

 

The same approach reaches beyond variation orders. A contractor could prove work is complete before a progress payment is released, and suppliers could prove delivery against purchase orders. Subcontractors, who feel late payment most because it flows down the chain, could be paid automatically once the main contractor receives its money. Outside construction, Dr Chai sees the framework fitting any procurement where parties must prove compliance without exposing their prices, such as government procurement or infrastructure concessions.

 

His hope for the next five years fits into one line he would like to hear in every variation order meeting: 'check the blockchain' replaces 'check your email' as the first response whenever a variation order comes up. He borrows the reasoning from author Stephen M.R. Covey, who wrote that when trust goes up, speed goes up and cost goes down.

 

'In our construction industry, that trust still has a long way to go,' Dr Chai reflects. 'We hope this research brings it closer.'

Interested in research like this? You can join this research direction through your own postgraduate study. If your background is in construction management, quantity surveying or computer science, you could explore dissertation topics that build on PriVOChain, from blockchain-based procurement to smart contract design and privacy-preserving verification. The School of Architecture, Building and Design offers the Master of Science in Virtual Design and Construction and the Doctor of Philosophy in Architecture. Speak to one of our education counsellors to explore your options and find the right path for you.

YOU MIGHT BE INTERESTED
{{ item.articleDate ? vm.formatDate(item.articleDate) : '' }}
{{ item.readTime }} Min Read